Tag Archives: G.K. Chesterton

Heretics by G.K. Chesterton

I’m too tired to think of a good blog post tonight, and there are no updates on TG, so please enjoy this review I recently wrote.

I challenged myself in 2024 to re-read the books that impacted me most in my 20s. Orthodoxy by G.K. Chesterton ranked high on that list. But I realized that to really re-read Orthodoxy, I first needed to start at the beginning of the debate, with the shots fired in Heretics. (And truly, this book is shots fired! Chesterton has no problem tackling all the big thinkers of his day and explaining Why They Are Wrong.)

It is a curious books in many respects. Published in 1905, Heretics stands at a weird crossroads halfway through the Edwardian era. WW1 is still a murky 9 years or so off. Joseph Chamberlain is the British politician garnering Chesterton’s wrath; his son will yet become Neville Chamberlain who infamously attempted to appease Hitler.

The thinkers of the day garnering Chesterton’s critique will be familiar in our English lit courses but not necessarily for their brands of philosophy. Chesterton kicks off by analyzing the public writing of Rudyard Kipling, H.G. Wells, and Bernard Shaw.

The first half of this book, where Chesterton stays (mostly) on track by focusing on other thinkers, is the most digestible and most practical. He then veers off at random points to vent about cowardly journalists, the fallacy of “young” nations, and the problem with identifying certain attributes with race. (Particularly interesting in light of Europe’s next few decades.)

As you might expect with Chesterton, no matter what his topic, he has the best one liners. A few favorites:

“Scotland continues to be educated and Calvinistic; England continues to be uneducated and happy.”

“Drink because you are happy, but never because you are miserable.”

But he also has a way of expressing big thoughts with few words, meaning it often takes a while to fully grasp what he is saying. But when you do, it sure packs a wallop. Take the following few sentences and think about modern discourse on social media:

“There is nothing really narrow about the clan; the thing which is really narrow is the clique. The men of the clan live together because they all wear the same tartan or are all descended from the same sacred cow; but in their souls, by the divine luck of things, there will always be more colors than in any tartan. But the men of the clique live together because they have the same kind of soul, and their narrowness is a narrowness of spiritual coherence and contentment, like that which exists in hell.”

This was certainly a solid start to my re-reads.


2021 Reading Challenge: My 5 Star Reads

I know not everyone had the time or inclination to read 272 books, so I’m cutting to the chase and giving you a list of my favorite reads from 2021.

(Only one post for my 5-star reads this year! I had five last year!)

City of God by Saint Augustine

Ever wondered how sex worked in the Garden of Eden? Why Seth’s genealogy lists more people than Cain’s? Why there were three levels on the ark? Yeah, me neither. But somehow it works. This classic work of Christian theology is over a thousand pages long and broadly covers philosophy, history, apologetics, myth, and Pythagorean theory. Topics range from the founding of Rome to the calling of Abraham to prophesies about the apocalypse. Intense, often random, but worth it.

The New Rules for Love, Sex, and Dating by Andy Stanley

An excellent, practical look at relationships that I found more useful than I expected. The book walks a healthy line of extending grace while also explaining many of the pitfalls inherent in modern dating culture. Stanley writes as a Christian but not necessarily for Christians. The basic idea is that a person should examine what they want in a relationship and work to improve themselves rather than focusing on finding the “right” person.

A Conflict of Visions: Ideological Origins of Political Struggles by Thomas Sowell

This is a fantastic foundation if you want to explore the political and philosophical divide that separates the U.S. today. As always with Sowell, it is intellectual stimulating but easy to read. And honestly, despite the publishing date of 1986, more than half the time it felt like a book that could have been written today.

Wired Love: A Romance of Dots and Dashes by Ella Cheever Thayer

This is the story of Nathalie Rogers, a telegraph operator who strikes up a friendship with a male telegraph operator down the line. They spend every day chatting and he becomes an instrumental part of her life. But you can’t fall in love with someone you’ve never met in person…can you? Published in 1879, this book reads like a modern day internet romance! So, so cute. Worth picking up free on Kindle.

The Man Who Was Thursday: A Nightmare by G.K. Chesterton

I always say that I read G.K. Chesterton to better understand C.S. Lewis. And once again, I feel like I understand Aslan better because I’ve met Sunday. This is a wild ride of a story complete with anarchists, elephants, and the nature of God. Especially if you enjoy Chesterton’s nonfiction, you will love this story.

Sexy: The Quest for Erotic Virtue in Perplexing Times by Jeff Mallinson

Despite the titillating title, this book provides a fairly uncontroversial thesis: Christians should never treat love transactionally. Agape love should infuse all Christian relationships, especially romantic ones. It then explores what that looks like within the bounds of human sexuality. Topics range from relatively familiar harangues against Josh Harris’s I Kissed Dating Goodbye to more controversial subjects like porn and masturbation. Overall I found this book handled things well and challenged some of my core assumptions about sexuality.

The Vanishing American Adult: Our Coming-Of-Age Crisis–And How to Rebuild a Culture of Self-Reliance by Ben Sasse

I like this book because Sasse doesn’t just highlight a problem with our modern society: he provides a solution. He very intentionally avoids high-profile political issues and focuses on commonality. His goal is bridge-building over dissension. It is a refreshing approach in our highly polarized society. This is a practical work about coming of age and adulthood. It left me with several provoking thoughts, including my own inclination towards consumerism.

The Grown Woman’s Guide to Online Dating: Lessons Learned While Swiping Right, Snapping Selfies, and Analyzing Emojis by Margot Starbuck

If you told me at the beginning of the year that one of my favorite books of 2021 would be a guide to online dating…I’d call you crazy. Because online dating? Not a collection of funny essays about online dating, but a breakdown on how to create a good profile, set strong boundaries, and avoid red flags? All wrapped in a message about identity, hope, and faith from an amazing, funny, and vulnerable woman? Yes. It is one of my favorites. I’d go so far as to recommend this to any woman regardless of your relationship status because it is just dang encouraging and fun to read.

Dignity: Seeking Respect in Back Row America by Chris Arnade

Much like reading Hillbilly Elegy, I appreciate this book because it puts into words feelings I struggle to express. The feelings of Milwaukee, of rural Tennessee, of agrarian Iowa, of the bayous of Louisiana, of life in towns where the jobs left but community stayed. This is primarily a book of photos designed to grapple with poverty and respect. It doesn’t always do it perfectly. But it provides a challenging and sometimes inspiring look at where people gather in the community and the common humanity that unites urban and rural Americans.

Charter Schools and Their Enemies by Thomas Sowell

The story begins in the 1970s. Thomas Sowell started researching academic excellence in all black schools. He thought the evidence would play an important role in education reform. Instead, his narrative—competing as it did with more popular theories about education policy—went mostly ignored. In a sense, this is his answer years later. He’s coming back and hitting hard with the data. And does he ever come with the data. More than half the page count in this book comes from the Appendix and Notes. Very well cited and yet somehow super readable.

Total Truth: Liberating Christianity from Its Cultural Captivity by Nancy R. Pearcey

While not much of this book introduced something new to me, it succinctly laid out the argument for a Christian worldview and the many ways the church has shied away from our Christian foundation over the years. She makes the case for a broader view of Christian vocation, intellectual discourse, and clear doctrine. This is a practical, useful book to challenge how you approach the world and how we present ourselves as Christians.


2020 Reading Challenge: My 5 Star Reads (Part 2)

I read 400 books in 2020. Here are some of my (eclectic) favorites:

Bronze Age America by Barry Fell

The next time someone asks me which dead author I would want to have dinner with, I think I’m going to have to answer “Barry Fell.” If his dinner conversation is even a tenth as full of personality as his book, he’d be someone worth knowing. Fell is extremely passionate about the fact that Bronze Age Nordic Europeans sailed to modern day Canada and traded with “Amerindians.” Apparently in the 1980s this was a highly controversial claim (perhaps it still is?) because in this book he’s determined to prove he isn’t crazy. And he does so by jumping from archaeology to oceanography to linguistics, from Africa to Ireland to Canada, from Nordic myths to carbon dating to funeral rites, all with barely a breath in-between. It is a hilarious, wild ride…though I doubt he meant it to be. I stayed up till the wee hours reading I was so entertained.

Political Writings by Immanuel Kant

The introduction of my edition makes two striking points: 1. You should just learn German if you want to understand Kant. 2. Kant is a dry writer with occasionally brilliant sentences. I found both true. (Presumably true. I don’t speak German so apparently I don’t understand Kant. But this was a fascinating read!)

The Duchess of Malfi by John Webster

Written in 1614, this play is a tragedy and * spoiler alert * everyone dies. But oh, what tragic, beautiful deaths they have. It left me slightly teary-eyed, which takes doing.

Babette’s Feast by Isak Dinesen

A short story about the power of gourmet food, Babette’s Feast came highly recommended and did not disappoint. It is a story of two austere women who take in a French refugee. She in turn repays their kindness with cooking. I don’t want to give too much away, but I would highly recommend reading with a book club if possible.

The First and Second Discourses by Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Rousseau is not my favorite philosopher by any stretch of the imagination but I have to give credit for his impact on Western civilization. He raised many valid critiques with how we operate in society. There is a reason people struggle with the paradox in his writings well over 200 years later. Worth a read–the Judith R. Masters translation is particularly excellent.

Symposium by Plato

In which Socrates drinks everyone under the table, Alcibiades publicly admits his crush on Socrates, and Plato sets the foundation for how we think about love in the Western world. Not bad for 90 pages.

The Federalist Papers by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, John Jay

Well, it took over a decade, but I finally cleared The Federalist Papers. I think the problem is I went in expecting theory and got procedure instead. This is the nitty-gritty details of constitutional governance. The letters reference historical examples and quote political philosophers, but mostly to explain why the constitution was written the way it was. Practical, useful, insightful, even, but not something you want to curl up with on a rainy day.

Gilead by Marilynne Robinson

Throw a phrase like “an intimate tale of three generations” into a book description and I’ll usually run in the opposite direction. It sounds so threateningly of intergenerational conflict and simmering angst. And “an intimate tale of three generations” is exactly what this book promises. But Gilead pleasantly surprised me. It is the story of an elderly pastor writing to his young son about all the things he will never be able to tell him–things about their family, of prodigal sons, and of the town Gilead. The book tackles themes of grace, parenthood, and faith. It is complex in spirit but short enough in length to make it a surprisingly fast read. I didn’t expect to, but I loved it.

All Things Considered by G.K. Chesterton

Here is the thing about G.K. Chesterton: he begins discussing Christmas traditions, veers off into why he anti-vivisectionist, and concludes with turkey. (As in the bird.) Somewhere in-between he drops an aside about the king’s crown and “Tolstoian non-resistance.” It ought to come across entirely nonsensical and yet over a hundred years later, I read it and go… “Oh, why, that applies to what is happening today! It is like he wrote for 2020!” You never know what you will get but you can be confident it will be worth it.

Life Together: The Classic Exploration of Faith in Community by Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Don’t be fooled by how innocently short this book looks: it packs a punch! In a hundred pages, Bonhoeffer lays out the role of personal prayer, worship in common, everyday work, and Christian service in Christian community. You might not agree with everything but you will certainly be challenged


Favorite Books By Favorite Authors

Yesterday I shared my Top 10 Favorite Authors. Being a bookworm, I could not possibly create a similarly short list for my favorite books. (Or if I did, it would mostly just be C.S. Lewis and Georgette Heyer books.) But I can list my favorite book from each of my favorite authors…and that is kind of like a top 10 book list! (Except this was REALLY HARD.)

1. C.S. Lewis—The Weight of Glory

2. Georgette Heyer—The Grand Sophy

3. Mary Stewart—This Rough Magic

4. Berta Ruck—In Another Girl’s Shoes

5. Agatha Christie—Murder on the Orient Express

6. Jean Webster—Daddy Long Legs

7. G.K. Chesterton—Orthodoxy

8. Dorothy L. Sayers—Are Women Human? Astute and Witty Essays on the Role of Women in Society

9. Helene Hanff—84 Charing Cross Road

10. Elizabeth George Speare—The Witch of Blackbird Pond


Top 10 Favorite Authors

To celebrate hitting 2,500 books read on Goodreads today, I thought it would be fun to revisit my Top 10 Favorite authors. I noticed an odd theme…

  1. C.S. Lewis

2. Georgette Heyer

3. Mary Stewart

4. Berta Ruck

Berta Ruck Net Worth 2020 Update: Bio, Age, Height, Weight ⋆ Net Worth Roll

5. Agatha Christie

6. Jean Webster

7. G.K. Chesterton

8. Dorothy L. Sayers

9. Helene Hanff

10. Elizabeth George Speare

In other words, you can narrow my favorite authors to the era of “they had photography but it wasn’t colored yet.”